And That’s a Salad!

I’m sure every family has a Jell-O Salad recipe tucked away in an old cookbook somewhere, perhaps passed down from the generation that lived when Jell-O was first named by Pearl B. Wait’s wife, Mary, in 1897.

Ours is Lime Jell-O Salad and has become a tradition to make and eat every Thanksgiving.

Reading the ingredient list is far from appetizing though. Who ever came up with such a thing??? Marshmallows, lime jello, cream cheese and crushed pineapple are fine and dandy, but then it gets crazy. Let’s add a tub of Cool-Whip to that (Do we even know what Cool-Whip is?). Oh! And how about a bottle of 7-up! And mayonnaise, like, everything has to have mayonnaise.

What?!!! Was this the result of a recipe contest sponsored by Hellmann’s, Dr. Pepper, Kraft Cool-Whip and Jell-o?

Oh, and we’ll call it a salad.


Definition of Salad from Oxford Dictionary


cold dish of various mixtures of raw or cooked vegetables, usually seasoned with oil, vinegar, or other dressing and sometimes accompanied by meat, fish, or other ingredients: a green salad [mass noun]: bowls of salad

And it fits the bill…why?

I’m not sure. Still trying to figure that one out.

Hmmm…What else can I add…

It is green…

Maybe the inventor thought a name like that would make people think it was healthy.

Anyway, the traditional maker of our said traditional salad rebelled this year refusing to mix up such awful ingredients and serve it as food. Then I had an idea. How hard would it be to make a healthier version of a Jell-o Salad? (Don’t flip out, Grandma. :D )

I already had homemade marshmallows in the pantry leftover from our camping trip to the Wichita Mountains last weekend. The rest would be easy!

I decided on cherry instead of lime, since tradition was thrown to the wind anyway, and because I like cherries. I also couldn’t see using lime juice concentrate with pulp for the jello part, so cherry it is!

3/4 c. Old Orchard 100% cherry apple juice concentrate

3/4 c. water

4 c. homemade vanilla marshmallows

2 pkg. unflavored gelatin

6 oz. cream cheese, softened

10 oz. crushed pineapple, with juice

1 c. whipping cream

6 oz. Chobani Greek yogurt, cherry flavored

1 12 oz pkg frozen cherries, thawed

Combine  juice concentrate and water. Heat one cup of the mixture along with 2 cups marshmallows.

Dissolve 3 pkg of gelatin in the remaining juice.

Add the cream cheese and whisk until combined.

Don’t you love the snowflakes on Philadelphia’s seasonal packaging? :)

There might be flecks of cream cheese that won’t whisk in – don’t worry about it.
Trust me, it disappears.

Stir in gelatin.

Whip cream and fold in the yogurt…

And then the rest of the marshmallows. ( I cut them into bite sized pieces using kitchen scissors. )

Add cherries and pineapple. Isn’t that gorgeous?!!!

Stir in the gelatin/cream cheese mixture and pour into a serving bowl to chill and set.

Look what surfaced under the Chobani lid as I was creating this recipe –

Just add good.

Uh-uh! That’s my motto! :)

We shall see how everyone likes it on Thursday! (Personally, I think it’s fabulous… only it’s been talking to me from the refrigerator all day long. I ignore it. Of course.)

Happy Thanksgiving! Safe travels, thankful smiles, and happy eating to you all!


17 thoughts on “And That’s a Salad!

  1. Can’t wait to try this, Sarah. It looks wonderful. I’m excited. And…I’ll be honest…I feel a bit lost knowing we aren’t going to have sea foam salad this year. Yes, a moment of silence for our dear friend, lime jello salad.

    Okay….bring on the good! ;)

  2. Oh – cherries! What a wonderful looking salad, much more appetizing than the green concoction! My grandma makes a peach-jello type salad every Christmas, with a clear orange layer including sliced peaches and a lighter orange whipped layer. Her cranberry-jello salad always accompanies as well and they are quite the Christmas tradition! Along with the salads are, of course, the fancy-pants jello molds which can take your salad to a *whole new level* ;)

    Thanks for another great twist on a favourite old recipe!

  3. I’ve been wondering for days how this salad went over. I knew it would be good! We rarely have a jello salad, but I made one with the plastic whipped topping this year. I got the ingredients before I read this post……not that I would’ve tried anything close to what you did. I probably would’ve just skipped the whole thing!

    • Now I’m curious as to what flavor you made. I hadn’t thought of jello salad much up until now and I’m finding there’s a whole Jell-o world out there! :D

Throw your thoughts into the mix!

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s